Saturday, 9 February 2013

Savarkar the social reformer




Excerpts from the book “Savarkar and His times “ 1950 by Kheer Dhananjay .



Savarkar’s effort regarding “mixed-caste” schools


On of  first and foremost battle in Ratagiri Savarkar had with the Hindu orthodoxy was over the question of mixed-caste schools in the District. The orthodox Hindus opposed the idea tooth and nail. The School Board faltered and the District Board failed in its support.

Savarkar carried on intense propaganda in favor of mixed schools through the press and from the platform, and appealed to the District and Provincial authorities for help against the forces of orthodoxy which denied the just, civic, human, and legitimate rights to the children of the “untouchables” to sit in public schools along with the “caste-Hindu” children. Attention of the Government also was drawn by Savarkar to the fact that the untouchables being as good tax-payers and citizens as the touchable, their children were entitled to the benefit of a public schools. It was also pointed out that those very orthodox Hindus did not feel any qualms of conscience in allowing the Christian and Muslim children to sit with their children in the schools.

Savarkar entreated the orthodox Hindus in an appealing tone not to treat their co-religionists worse than dogs and cats. " You insult the untouchables, because they are ignorant and helpless; but you yield to the unjust demands of the Muslims because they are aggressive. When a Mahar becomes a Muslim or a Christian convert, you treat him as your equal. But as a Mahar he will not receive the same treatment. What a shame my countrymen ! “  he thundered. Savarkar appealed to the District Magistrate to bring the rowdy elements to book and wrote to him in a moving tone : " I wish, sir, to enlist not only your legal protection as a Magistrate, but also your human sympathies as a gentleman, in the cause." It may seem strange that Savarkar should have written for help to the Government of those days. But it must be noted that Savarkar is always uncompromising with untruth and injustice, and not with men and power. The breath of his ideology is the hatred of oppression in every form, not of personalities and authorities. The virility and sincerity of Savarkar in this cause ultimately triumphed. The District Magistrate saw things for himself, and wrote the following remark during one of his visits to the schools : "It is the good result of Mr. Savarkar's lectures that the untouchable boys have been allowed to sit mixed and get their education without any invidious distinction being made in their case ! "

Then came another shock to orthodoxy !   An untouchable teacher was transferred in 1928, to a school attended entirely by caste-Hindu children! The Sanatanists moved heaven and earth to get the order of the School Board rescinded, but to no purpose. The School Board threatened to close the school and the orthodox Hindus regained their civic sense! The effect was tremendous and historic. Due to this victory of Savarkar over orthodoxy and the establishment of rival mixed-caste schools by the Hindus, and consequently for want of new converts, the American Mission working in Ratnagiri had to wind up its activities, and its chief departed in despair . Thus ended the first battle at Ratnagiri against orthodoxy in a unique victory for Savarkar.

Temple entry to “untouchables”

The question of Temple Entry for the untouchables cropped up in 1925. The orthodox quarters were alarmed. They shouted that their Religion, God and Traditions were in danger. Their religion and traditions and customs welcomed an untouchable provided he became a Mohammad or a Minto. The orthodox touched animals like bullocks and buffaloes, could endure the presence of a dog or a cat in their houses, but not the presence of their co-religionist Hindu Mahars or Hindu Bhangis though they were human beings!! They feared that their sacred God would be polluted by the mere sight of a Hindu Bhangi! “He is not God who can be desecrated " went the epigrammatic Savarkarian reply to the orthodox. Savarkar holds that those men, who regard such inhuman faith as abhors the touch of a human being, and yet gladly touches animals like dogs and cats, are themselves a blot on humanity. It is they who are really fallen and not the " untouchables " ! Removal of untouchability, therefore,. Implies purification and salvation of such misguided orthodox touchables also!


Pan-Hindu Ganesh Festivals:

Orthodoxy began to collapse under such ruthless arguments. To pull down the steel walls of orthodoxy, Savarkar started Pan-Hindu Ganesh festivals in 1925.   He transformed the Ganesh Festival started by Tilak into a Pan-Hindu Festival. An untouchable was not allowed for ages within the precincts of the Hindu sanctuaries    By and by the question of temple entry was discussed with wisdom and vehemence during the days of Ganesh Festival    The untouchables were brought into the hall of the Vithoba Temple in Ratnagiri, the most important temple in the Ratnagiri District. Then in November 1929, took place an event of far-reaching consequences. All the city was agog.   The City Magistrate was present by  a special order to see that the proceedings of the public meeting, held in the Vithoba Temple of Ratnagiri to decide the question of the entry of the untouchables into the Vithoba Temple, came off peacefully.

The momentous meeting began. Savarkar's convincing speech swept away doubts, hesitation and misgivings which were lurking in the minds of the opponents.
The Magistrate himself having been carried off his feet by the force and faith of Savarkar's speech, forgot his entity, rose and exclaimed, " Now who and what remain to be convinced ? " None came forward. It was a unique triumph for Savarkar. Amidst flickering opposition and deafening exclamations, the untouchables entered the Vithoba Temple of Ratnagiri, step by step, singing gracefully and gratefully the glory of " one God, one goal, one language, one country and one Nation." With great feelings and devotional eyes the densely crowded meeting saw the historic spectacle, the first of its kind in the history of Hindusthan! As the age-long sufferers followed their children who climbed the steps of the temple one by one, singing the song, their hearts throbbed, and eyes glowed. The song was especially composed in Marathi by Savarkar himself for the occasion! It read :

“The Impurity of ages is gone Scripture-born stamp is torn The age-long struggle is ended The net of enemies shredded The slave of ages hoary ! Now is a brother in glory!”


The Bhageshwar Temple in the Ratnagiri Fort was also declared open to all Hindus at a meeting held under the chairmanship of Shrimat Shankaracharya, the religious head of the Hindus. Sri Shankaracharya was garlanded on the occasion by a Hindu Bhangi as the representative of the Ratnagiri Hindus. The scene was reminiscent of the first Shankaracharya, who had embraced centuries ago a pantheist untouchable while returning from his bath in the Ganges !

A Pan-Hindu band was trained and it replaced the non-Hindu bands. The Hindu band attended festivals and functions. Women of Ratnagiri performed to the shock of Maharashtra and Hindustan their Haldi-Kumkum ceremony on a Pan-Hindu basis. During the Pan-Hindu Ganpati festivals a Bhangi Hindu sang Vedic hymns and Gayatri Mantram, the sacred privilege enjoyed so far by the Brahmins alone. The incident echoed throughout India. The Times of India, Bombay, styled it as a sacrilegious prize. The event resounded through some London papers too ! On another occasion a Bhangi family needed a priest; for a marriage ceremony. The Mahar Hindus being the Brahmins of the Bhangis, their priest declined to perform the ceremony. The Hindu Sabha thereupon sent a Brahmin priest, and he performed the ceremony.

Patit Pavan Temple:-

Patit pavan mandir Ratnagiri Maharashtra
Soon the movement gained ground and grew gradually popular. While the struggle for opening temples to the untouchables was forging ahead, Savarkar was thinking of having a Pan-Hindu Temple with a view to giving an impetus to the temple entry movement. He held that the youths trained in the new ideology would throw open the doors of the remaining temples to the untouchables when they would become trustees of the temples. So he approached Seth Bhagoji Baloji Keer, the famous temple-builder of Maharashtra, who fervently believed that Savarkar's inspiration was God's call ! He summarily and spontaneously silenced Savarkar's opponents by telling them that Savarkar's name was Vinayak and Vinayak was the name of God Ganapati! Indifference to Savarkar's wishes Seth Bhagoji built in February 1931 a magnificent temple known as the Patit Pavan Temple in Ratnagiri wherein all Hindus irrespective of caste could assemble for prayers. This was an epoch-making achievement of Savarkarian movement. This monumental Pan-Hindu temple was the first to stand in the history of Hindusthan open for Pan-Hindu worship, Pan-Hindu functions and Pan-Hindu propaganda. An event of new hope, new era, new light, and new history !

The opening ceremony of the temple came off on a grand scale. Acharyas, Shankaracharyas, pundits and patriots declared Ratnagiri a place of pilgrimage. In fact, as one speaker then put it, Ratnagiri became the new Kashi of the re-awakened, purified and unified Hindudorn where a Hindu scavenger acted as a priest, persons from the so-called Depressed Classes delivered Kathas, Mahars read the sacred Gita, Brahmins garlanded and bowed themselves before these priests and kathekaries; and Brahmin youths conducted a Pan-Hindu Hotel. Indeed, the Patit Pavan Temple came to be the university of the Pan-Hindu Movement.

Prohibition of one caste from dining with another was the keystone upon which the arch of the caste system mainly rested. Savarkar decided to strike a fatal blow at this keystone. He contemplated inter-caste Pan-Hindu dinners. As usual orthodox Hindus opposed the idea vehemently. Savarkar, however, silenced their learned spokesmen by throwing at their faces extracts from their own scriptures and Holy Works that sang that God Krishna dined with Vidura, a son born of a maid-servant, and that their great Brahmin Rishi, Durvasa, dined along with his numerous disciples at the Pandavas* who were Kshatriyas ! Yet, it was not easy to hold a Pan-Hindu dinner. The movement developed gradually from private quarters to public places. And then came off the first public Pan-Hindu dinner popularly known all over India as Sahabhojan, in a theatre in 1930. This was the acid test to know who were the real seasoned reformers and who were seasonal. What a horrifying event it was in the eyes of old traditions ! Upto this time even the beggars recoiled from touching the food of the Pan-Hindu dinner. Mahars refused to eat with the Bhangis and Bhangis with the Dhors. The Depressed Classes desired to eat with the caste-Hindus but not with the different sub-classes from amongst themselves. Onlookers thronged to see the neo-function, and Ratnagiri was the subject of headlines all over India.

All caste dinner

In its " current topics " the Times of India, Bombay, writing on the subject, observes in its issue of December 9, 1930 : "This all-caste dinner was celebrated in a unique manner? a manner that has given deep offence to Nationalist Congressmen, who are mostly believers along with Mr. Gandhi in four watertight castes by birth. For, at Ratnagiri some enthusiastic reformers, who regarded caste system as the bane of Hinduism, held an all-caste dinner which was attended by Brahmins, Banias, Chamars, Mahars and Bhangis!" Styling it as a bold creed, the writer goes on : " What is still more interesting, the spirit of this splendid essay in practical reform, Mr. V. D. Savarkar, delivered a speech in which he flung into the teeth of orthodoxy the daring credo of his party. “From today I shall not believe in highness or lowness of caste. I shall not oppose the intermarriage between the highest and lowest castes. I shall eat with any Hindu irrespective of caste. I shall not believe in caste by birth or by profession and henceforth I shall call myself a Hindu only? not Brahmin, Vaishya, etc "
Savarkar incessantly preached : " Eat with anybody. Eat anything that is medically fit and clean. That does not deprive you of your religion. Remember the root of religion is not the dish or the stomach, but the heart, soul and the blood! " The names of those persons, who took part in the all-caste dinners, were published in newspapers to the surprise and shock of their orthodox relations !


The first week of the opening ceremony of the Patit Pavan Temple saw the biggest of such Pan-Hindu Dinners in India. The reactions to the Pan-Hindu dinner were tremendous. Acharyas took to their heels and saints went head over heels. Cow-worshippers thought it beneath their dignity to honour human beings and eat with men who were their co-religionists ! There were some who did everything else for the movement, but declined to eat with all classes. Their heads agreed, but hearts disagreed ! At last their dilemma was solved, when Savarkar, who held that social reforms settled down more permanently if they were effected with full consideration and conciliation, accepted a compromise which allowed the no-changers to take their dinner by sitting not in the line with the revolutionary reformists, but in another row facing them. Orthodoxy clamored and raised a hue and cry in the city ! Rumours were afloat in the neighbouring villages that the all-caste dinner would cost the reformers dear and that a rift was visible in the ranks of the reformers.

When the beggars saw lawyers, leaders, Divans, merchants, doctors, big and respectable men of all castes sharing food in a communion, they, too, expressed their willingness to accept the Pan-Hindu food which they had declined to accept on the previous occasion ! But now Savarkar would not offer them the food unless they also sat in one and the same row irrespective of castes. And ultimately they did so ! At last Pan-Hindu sense and mentality came to stay. Karmaveer V. R. Shinde, a great social reformer of the Deccan, rejoiced to see what his D. C. Mission aimed at was both preached and practised in Ratnagiri. Overwhelmed with grateful tears, he acclaimed Savarkar as the real Patit Pavan of the Hindus, the saviour of the fallen and trodden. It was a noble appreciation and correct assessment of a great achievement! Some leaders, who witnessed the practical reforms, called Savarkar Sanghatanacharya? Master-brain at organization and others described him as their Shankaracharya, the supreme head of New Hinduism I

Dealing with orthodox Hindus

Every revolution has its convulsions and revelations. Defeated at all other points orthodox Hindus and non-Hindus now threatened Savarkar's life. In many families dissensions arose. Unpleasant words were said and heard between sons and fathers, wives and husbands. Harsh gestures were exchanged between friends, and estrangement rankled amongst relations. Newly married girls were forbidden to see the faces of their reformist parents, brothers or relatives. A married girl in one case perished in her illness despite her father's fervent entreaties to her father-in-law to send her to him for medical treatment. The father of the girl was asked to withdraw his support and devotion to Savarkarian ideology, but he did not yield !Half-hearted reformists were trapped and they repented in sack-cloth and ashes. If some one from Savarkar's camp fell ill, whispers and vilification would attribute the illness or misfortune to God's wrath ; and Savarkar would retort that “even his cat was still unaffected. All the while Savarkar infused courage into the minds of his followers with his undying dictum : " Reform implies always a minority, custom means a majority. Have undeviating faith in your mission and courage of conviction, and you will successfully overcome the forces of reactionaries ! "

Savarkarian Model of social reforms

This was the model moulded in a District-wide movement of Savarkarian Revolution which echoed throughout Hindu-sthan and had its reverberations even in the London papers. Savarkar succeeded where prophets, philosophers and emperors had failed. A man who had to rot for fourteen youthful years in the most dreadful jail and again was interned for over another thirteen years in Ratnagiri and was forbidden to participate publicly or privately in any political activities, had worked this miracle. All this happened a considerable time before Gandhiji made the Harijan uplift one of the chief planks of his activities !

Savarkar's approach to untouchability, the age-long corroding current of evil, and his potent remedy and method for its abolition were as rational and constructive as they were fearless, fundamental and far-reaching. There had been in the past rationalists like Agarkar, and institutions like the Arya Samaj, the Brahmo Samaj and the Prarthana Samaj working for that cause. Later, there followed also the great personality of Gandhiji in the field. There were some showy, touchy, and fashionable learned men who expressed lip sympathy in spotless diction for the Depressed Classes in order to please and show the ruling bosses their radical views ! But Savarkar's angle of vision fundamentally differed from those of such institutions and personalities. Western ideas of Equality, Fraternity arid Liberty dominated the motives of the rationalist group led by Ranade. Revolt against orthodox Hinduism and re-orientalization of Hinduism were the objects of the Arya Samaj ; electicism was the aim of the Brahmo Samaj and Prarthana Samaj. Agarkar was an unbridled rationalist, a lonely giant. He had no genius for constructive work. The Arya Samajists compromised their prophet's stand by mixing their identity with the Gandhian principles, lost sight of its political impact, and lost their vitality, fervour, and firmness ! Though Gandhi believed in the caste system, he wanted to remove untouchability. But his Harijan movement was anything but Hindu, though tb money for the cause came mainly from the Hindus

Gandhiji never raised his little linger against the proselytizing greed of the Maulavies and Missionaries and observed reticence about it! But even then it was his fortune that he received wreaths for his work for the Depressed Classes while Savarkar faced the wrath of all non-Hindu missionaries ! Like all positive and powerful reformers, Savarkar wielded the force, construction and hammer of Luther ! And a Luther is not born for laurels. Savarkar's one aim was to purge Hinduism of its most baneful superstitions and orthodox bigotry. His reformative zeal did not aim at the denunciation of Hinduism. He strove for its revival in the light of modern times and to ensure its survival. That was why he was offensive inside and defensive outside. He aimed at moulding the different castes of the Hindus into a classless Hindu society in which all Hindus would be by birth socially, economically and politically equal ! Rational, nationalistic and revolutionary in outlook, his ideology was as deep-rooted as it was far-reaching, and looked to the prosperity and peace of the Hindu society, Hindu life, Hindusthan and ultimately universal welfare. His was not the work of a fashionable reformer, or a showy rationalist, or a wordy humanist. His was a mission for a great cause for the emergence of Hindu-sthan as a world power to play her destined part in the comity of nations.

Two decades ago he admonished the Hindus to break off the seven shackles that hindered the progress of the Hindu society. He fought for temple entry, popularised Pan-Hindu dinners, naturalised Shuddhi-reconversion, annihilated the belief in highness and lowness of birth, favored inter caste marriages, and ridiculed the injunctions on caste-ridden vocations and sea-voyage. The power and faith of the Savarkarian movement depended for its vitality and goal upon the elixir of Shuddhi and Science which hold the key not only to Indian peace and prosperity, but also to the destinies of the Middle East and Far East, the one-time tributaries of Hindu life ! In one of his songs he visualized that the Hindus after achieving freedom would liberate all subject nations under the sun, and would help them establish love, equality and peace for the progress of humanity. And it was towards this end that all his Sanghatanist movement was directed. Savarkar preached and worked for the abolition of untouchability wilh unparalleled success when few of his great contemporaries were thinking of the removal of the untouchability, and a majority of them had not gauged its significance.

Restricted in his activities, shadowed by spies, Savarkar thus shelled one of the strongest holds of the Hindu orthodoxy in India. For this signal achievement he applied the battery of his oratory, poured in his volcanic energy, utilized the fund of his resourceful erudition and the flow of his volcanic pen. He used platform, press, examination centres, theatres, circus-tents, festivals, fares and functions for popularizing the Movement, and whipped the people into a revolt. The forces of conservatism and orthodoxy tottered before his powerful personality, and the bees that had nestled in the barriers of the caste system tried to fling their poisonous stings into his body, but failed. For, every Luther is born with an impenetrable armour !

The revolution in the Ratnagiri District was an unparalleled success; so much so that Karma veer Shinde, hearing the news of Savarkar's unconditional release in May 1937, remarked that had Savarkar's activities been restricted to social revolution only, he would have banished untouchability altogether from the face of India within five years. Worthy was the glowing tribute and noble appreciation made by a writer in a special issue of Dr. Ambedkar's Janata that Savarkar's service to the cause of the untouchables was as decisive and great as that of Gautama Buddha himself. Sri Kakasahib Barve, his contemporary, and President, Maharashtra Provincial Harijan Sevak Sangh, in his Presidential Address at a Conference at Sangli, in July 1945, expressed the view that had Savarkar continued his intense work in the cause of the removal of untouchability, his contribution would have given a tremendous impetus to the movement!
Thus it can be seen that the itality of Lord Buddha, who raised a revolt against untoud; ability, the virility of Shivaji, who purposefully hammered its corners that lay in his way, the vigour of Dayananda, whc> strove to bury it, are all crystallized in the revolutionary philosophy of Savarkar whose approach to the problem v: predominantly political and fundamentally social.

Upliftment of dalits the “Savarkarian” way

Savarkar's propaganda was not one-sided. With a batch of his workers, he visited the slums and squalid dens, hamlets and hills, villages and towns where the untouchables lived, This batch studied their ways of living, taught them cleanliness, guided them, and worshipped with them. They took the Chambhars into the quarters and temples of the Mahars and the Bhangis into the quarters and temples of the Dhors.

The discussions and debates with opponents over the burning problem of Shuddhi-Reconversion and Hindu organisation stormed and abated. Stirring speeches and moving appeals would go on till early dawn. The next morning saw Savarkar in another village and so his propaganda went on. Savarkar was then in the best of his health. Men of wealth, distinction and status followed him climbing zig-zag distances and dales with cheer. In fact, all the Indian leaders, whose names are connected with the removal of untouchability, have not seen as many quarters of the untouchables as Savarkar has done. The suppressed humanity watched and sat far into the night with bewilderment and hope, and crowded for the darshan of Savarkar, the Saviour of the fallen Hindus, who opened to them the gates of the Temples of God, Man and Light!
Savarkar also attended and presided over the conferences of the so-called untouchables. In June 1929 he was received with great ovation at Malvan in the southern part of the Ratnagiri District, where he presided over the Conference of the Depressed Classes of the Konkan Division. The Conference sang Vedic hymns in a body. Savarkar distributed the sacred threads among the so-called untouchable Hindus and declared amid great applause : " A battle royal has been raging for the last seven generations over the right of studying the Vedas. Here are the Vedas. Here is the sacred thread. Take these two. Is that all ? Even non-Hindus read the Vedas. Why should not the Hindu Mahars read them ? The feud over this problem was a useless task. Let us expiate the sins we committed. We are all responsible for our political subjugation. That is the past. Now let us declare on oath that we shall rectify our past blunders and win back our weal, wealth and glory." Sri P. N. Rajbhoj, a volatile leader of the Depressed Classes from Poona, who was present at the Conference, observed : "I was really sceptical of the Savarkarian movement at the beginning. My contact and discussions with Barrister Savarkar and my personal observation have thoroughly convinced me of its far-reaching effect. I am extremely rejoiced to declare that this famous leader of the political revolutionaries is also an out and out social revolutionist ! "

Another notable Conference was held in the Patit Pavan Temple at Ratnagiri just after the temple was opened during the last week of February 1931, under the aegis of the D.C. Mission led by Karmaveer V. R. Shinde. This was the Mission's Sixth Annual Session and was presided over by Savarkar. All the workers and leaders of the D.C. Mission and other leaders of the so-called Depressed Classes were thrilled to survey the achievement of this Savarkarian movement. One after another they acknowledged gratefully that their dreams were brought into reality by Savarkar in Ratnagiri. They repeated that if the atmosphere of Ratnagiri captivated all the parts of India, there would be no untouch-ability left in the land.


A third Conference was held on April 26, 1931. It was the Ratnagiri District Somavanshiya Mahar Conference. Savarkar presided over it. It was attended by hundreds of Mahars from all corners of the District. The Mahars had poured in the city as they heard that ' Pandhari' was shifted to Ratnagiri where they were allowed to enter the temple and worship God?an unbelievable thing for them?a thing for which they had pined for ages ! Savarkar’s teachings and message to the untouchables were appealing. He asked them to live a simple life, and to shed their inherent inferiority complex. He admonished them : "Your weakness is worse than the wickedness of the caste Hindus. For your own welfare you must also suffer with fortitude and faith. You want rights, but you are net prepared to pay the price. Be men. Know that you arc men. If someone scolds you for your proximity on the public road, tell him that the public road is not the property of his father. Do not abandon your occupations. Stick to them and improve them. Every occupation has its value. Live a clean and temperate life. Never disown your fathers, saints, and blood. Do not observe untouchability among yourselves. Always treat with equality and kindness all the sub-castes amongst your own so-called Depressed Classes. That is also your duty. Forget it not! "



Savarkar's love of Hindu religion was not narrow-minded either. He said : " When a non-Hindu worships or a Mohammedan merges into humanity melting his religious libido, the Hindus, too, shall dissolve their separate entity." " Till then," Savarkar observed, "it is necessary that the Hindus should be within their bonds. It is against the creed of humanity itself, if we ignore stark realities of life." To the so-called caste Hindus his piece of advice was that they should be prepared to adopt even the pursuit of sweepers. There should be no monopoly in any field. He advised the non-Brahmins to administer to their own religious and sacramental life themselves and told them that there was no need of an authorised intermediary between them and God. " The moment you resolve not to invite the Bhat (Brahmin) to perform religious functions, Bhatshahi collapses like a pack of cards/' he wrote. Learning and expounding the scriptures or sacerdocy should not be the monopoly of one particular class. Prestige and authority should be justified by individual achievement and not by caste, he opined. Priests, irrespective of caste, should be certified as are our doctors, asserted Savarkar.

To the so-called caste Hindus his piece of advice was that they should be prepared to adopt even the pursuit of sweepers. There should be no monopoly in any field. He advised the non-Brahmins to administer to their own religious and sacramental life themselves and told them that there was no need of an authorised intermediary between them and God. " The moment you resolve not to invite the Bhat (Brahmin) to perform religious functions, Bhatshahi collapses like a pack of cards/' he wrote. Learning and expounding the scriptures or sacerdocy should not be the monopoly of one particular class. Prestige and authority should be justified by individual achievement and not by caste, he opined. Priests, irrespective of caste, should be certified as are our doctors, asserted Savarkar.

Friday, 8 February 2013

Madanlal Dhingra, Savarkar and assassination of lord Curzon


Excerpts from the book “Savarkar and His times “ 1950 by Kheer Dhananjay .

Madanlal Dhingra
Vinayak Damodar Savarkar
Madanlal Dhingra was a manly spirit, a man who looked into his open grave! Smartly dressed he looked like a dandy. He was a devoted follower of Savarkar and was proud of his nation. One day someone taunted him that the Japanese were the bravest people in Asia. Dhingra retorted that his Hindu Nation was nothing less in comparison. In the course of the talk, it was decided to test the mettle of Madanlal himself, A pin was pierced through his palm. Blood flowed out profusely, but Dhingra remained unperturbed.

Lord Curzon
A few days before Dhingra had asked his leader whether the time for martyrdom had really come. Out came the epigrammatic reply from Savarkar: " If a martyr is determined and ready that fact by itself generally implies that the time for martyrdom must have come," Dhingra then joined a jolly club where high-placed Englishmen attended. He crept into their confidence. There he learnt to shoot and gained closer knowledge of men like Lord Morley, Lord Curzon and Sir Curzon Wyllie. The living symbol of racial arrogance, the Bengal culprit and the enlightened despot, Lord Curzon was Dhingra's immediate target. A few days before at a meeting he had pursued this target with the eyes of a crocodile. But the doors of the Hall were closed in his face and restless Dhingra returned and said to Savarkar, " The tiger has escaped!" Determined to avenge the misdeeds the British Government perpetrated in India, he then fell on an equally responsible man, Sir William Curzon Wyllie, with the fierceness of a lion and achieved his end ! He was arrested forthwith. Two pistols, a knife and a dagger were found on his person. After the deed, the doctors who examined the victims were astounded to see Dhingra's pulse beating normal, for he was no common killer. Great was the strength and noblest was the soul of Madanlal. Dhingra was then put into the Brixton Jail. And proceedings against Dhingra commenced.

The incident shook London to its marrow ! Some unusual crowbar turned London upside down, as it were ! India was the subject in every British cottage, in every paper, in trains, in trams, at public squares and in markets, palaces and the British Parliament. The atmosphere became tense. Dhingra's father wired to Lord Morley that he was ashamed to own Madanlal as his son. Even Dhingra's brother in London publicly disowned him. Under the fiery eyes of the Britishers loyal Indians also trembled. Their holy tears overflowed. They assembled on the 5th of July in the famous Caxton Hall to condemn Dhingra. At the meeting Sir Mancherjee Bhow-nagari, Sir Aga Khan, Sir Surendranath Banerjee, Sri B. C. Pal and Sri Khaparcle were loud in their denunciation. The meeting was attended by Maharajkumar of Coochbihar, Sir Dinshaw Petit, Fazalbhoy Karimbhoy, etc. Just then Theodore Morrison, a member of the India Council, brought Madanlal’s brother on to the platform. Madanlal's brother spoke sentences which were not his own. Sir Aga Khan, the chairman, then declared, " The meeting unanimously condemns Madanlal Dhingra." But a defying voice from the thickly crowded Hall roared, " No, not unanimously." The chairman angrily uttered : " Who says no ? " Out came the reply, " I say no," The chairman pursued, " Your name please." Upon this some lost their patience and shouted, " Pull him down, drive him out! " In a moment Sir Mancherjee Bhownagari jumped from the platform and ran in the direction of the voice. The challenging voice shot back : " It is me. My name is Savarkar." At this the audience trembled in their joints. They feared that revolutionaries would now bomb the meeting* Women shrieked, non-partisans took to their heels and partisans came from words to blows. The chicken-hearted shook beneath benches and chairs ! In the heat of the passion a Eurasian swooped down upon Savarkar and struck him a blow on the forehead. Savarkar's face was besmeared with blood. His clothes were dripping, his spectacles broken to pieces. " With all this I say, I am against the resolution," he said standing as firm as a rock to maintain his opinion to the last drop of his blood. As he was saying this, Sri Tirumalacharya, who was standing by Savarkar, thrashed the head of the aggressor, one Mr. Palmer, and down went Palmer reeling. Sri Aiyer was about to shoot Palmer, but Savarkar winked at him and restrained him.

In the meanwhile Sir Surendranath had left the hall protesting against the cowardly attack on Savarkar. Sir Aga Khan also did not like the rashness of Sir Mancherjee. At last at the instance of Sir Mancherjee the police interfered, but, seeing that the truth was on Savarkar's side, they let him go. Savarkar also let the Eurasian go ! And the meeting ended.

Tossing from side to side in his bed with a fold of wet cloth on his forehead, Savarkar at his residence dictated a letter the very night for the London Times. With its publication he silenced all the hostile criticism against him. His arguments were irrefutable when he stated that, as the case of Dhingra was sub judice, the meeting had no right to usurp the powers of the court and condemn Madanlal in advance. Moreover, he had a right to record his vote! Thus did the historic meeting test the stuff of the leader of revolution and his knowledge of law ! Here one thing may be made clear. Had the meeting at the Caxton Hall sympathized with Lady Curzon Wyllie in her bereavement and done nothing else, Savarkar would have also sympathized with the poor lady. Savarkar was a poet and philosopher full of human attributes. Niranjan Pal, who was present at the meeting, dwells upon this great trait in Savarkar and observes : " The assassination of Sir Curzon Wyllie reminds me of another great trait in Savarkar's character, his humanity. An Indian student laughingly described how Lady Curzon Wyllie ran down the staircase and threw herself on the body of her husband. All this was too much for Savarkar. 'A wife sobs her heart out for her husband and you laugh at it! I do not trust you I cannot !' Savarkar had replied in burning indignation. It was a prophetic statement for, the very man secured the King's pardon by giving evidence against Savarkar."

When preliminary hearing of the Dhingra trial commenced on July 10, at the Westminster Court, despite the evil advice to feign madness, Dhingra boldly asserted that he wished that the English Court of Law should sentence him to death, for in that case the vengeance of his countrymen would be all the keener. He further said : " Just as the Germans have no right to occupy this country, so the English people have no right to occupy India; and it is perfectly justifiable on our part to kill the Englishman who is polluting our sacred land. I am surprised at the terrible hypocrisy, the farce and the mockery of the English people." Dhingra made this ex tempore statement as the written statement found on his person at the time of his arrest was suppressed by the police who said that no such statement was recovered at all. Dhingra was then committed to Sessions.

In India also there were sky-high denunciations of the deed of Madanlal. N. C. Kelkar, at one such protest meeting, asked his audience to uproot the doctrine of violence. He said it was a poisonous tree which must not be allowed to grow, even in neglected corners. Kelkar was indeed a man of elastic convictions. Afterwards, while writing the life of Garibaldi, he openly glorified the sacrifice of revolutionaries as the fertilizer of the nation ! Gokhale went one step further than Kelkar. He denounced the whole London group of about fifty revolutionaries and insinuated that their activities would not stop unless Savarkar was arrested.

Dhingra's Sessions trial was a formal affair. There, too, he repeated his demand that his statement suppressed by the police should be read, and offered no other defense. But the police persisted in their assumed ignorance of the statement as in the lower Court. The Court thereupon sentenced Dhingra to death and the trial ended.

Newspapers now directly attacked Savarkar as the source of the tragedy. In India his relations and colleagues were persecuted. Some lost their jobs, some their property and his father-in-law heroically faced sufferings. Harsh measures were adopted to crush the Indian students. Pandit Shyamji's Scholarship money for Spencer Lectureship was returned. The Pandit and Virendranath Chattopadhyaya lost their degrees as a result of their writings and propaganda. Though Savarkar passed the final examination of the Gray's Inn, the Benchers of his Inn declined to confer the degree upon him. Thereupon Savarkar made an appeal to the authorities of the Gray's Inn. They appointed a Committee to inquire into the affair. That Committee instituted an inquiry into the matter. Match as Savarkar was for the legal brains on the Committee and their cross-examination, nothing was proved against him though this Committee was aided by the Government of India. At last the Committee of the Gray's Inn decided to confer the degree upon Savarkar provided he gave them a written undertaking that he would never participate in politics. Savarkar rejected their offer in toto I Getting the degree was not his aim. His sole aim was to free his country and make it great and powerful. This barrister was not meant for conducting petty cases and amass wealth. He was the nation's barrister. He was destined to study the case of his Fatherland and put it before the world opinion as did Mazzini and Lenin. Hindusthan knows how from the sunshine of his youth to the golden evening of his life, he has been a loyal barrister all along defending and fighting for the absolute political Independence of India, her integrity and her honour.

Savarkar was now on the verge of physical collapse. For the last four years he had worked with a phenomenal energy. Persecution reached its climax. A yell of wrath fell on him from all quarters. As the India House was closed down just a few days before the Curzon Wyllie incident, Savarkar then resided for some days with Sri B. C. Pal. On the next day of Wyllie's death angry crowds stormed Pal's residence. Elder Pal told the mob that Savarkar was his guest and averted further consequences. Savarkar, however, thought it wise to leave his residence for their and his safety. Homeless, friendless, starving, stranded and shadowed by C.I.D., he wandered from lodge to lodge and house to house for shelter. But who shelters a defeated Guru Govind Singh ? Was not the defeated Tatya Tope betrayed ? And so in a single day Savarkar had to quit two lodgings. From one of these he was ousted even at midnight! The C.I.D. men followed his shadow. No sleep, no rest, no food ! At last a German landlady accepted him as a boarder for some days.

Fatigued and fagged out, Savarkar soon went to Brighton, a seaside English town, for a change.   It was here sitting by the side of Niranjan Pal on the beach that in overwhelming emotions filled with helplessness and hopelessness in a foreign land, the deserted youth sobbed his glorious moving poem " Take me O Ocean ! Take me to my native shores.    Thou promised me to take me home.    But thee coward, afraid of thy mighty master, Britain, thou hast betrayed me.   But mind my mother is not altogether helpless.    She will complain to sage Agasti and in a draught he will swallow thee as he did in the past." Several front rank poets and first-rate literary men of Maharashtra have regarded this poem as an unparalleled poem  on patriotism.    Foremost amongst  them  is the chief disciple of Gandhiji, Acharya Kaka Kalelkar, who described it as an inscription on the Marathi language. Acharya Atre, a front rank playwright and journalist, recently commented in his address at a literary Conference at Indore that every lofty idea in this pathetic song represented a specimen of great life and great poetry !   Thirty years after, describing the moving incident at Brighton, Niranjan Pal remarked :     "It has been my supreme good fortune to have met and known almost all the great patriots and personalities of modern India, but I have yet to know of a patriot who loved his Motherland as dearly as Vinayak Damodar Savarkar."

Even at Brighton Savarkar had an urgent feat to accomplish. It was the publication of Dhingra's suppressed statement before he was hanged. Savarkar, therefore, called his comrade, Gyanchand Varma, to Brighton and arranged for giving publicity to Dhingra's written statement which had been suppressed by the police. Two days gone, and Dhingra would jc in eternity. Savarkar, therefore, resolved that Dhingra must see the statement published. Accordingly Savarkar got the copies of Dhingra's statement printed and Varma posted them from Paris to different American and Irish' papers. It was difficult to find an English paper to publish the statement. But an Irishman working as an assistant editor on the Daily News undertook the job and inserted it in his paper during the night shift. The statement then exploded on the morning of the 16th August throughout London as a bombshell! The C.I.D. and police officers were sure it would never be published. It was in their possession. But they were outwitted and the statement entitled " Challenge " flashed throughout the world. The statement of Dhingra read as below :
I admit, the other day, I attempted to shed English blood as an humble revenge for the inhuman hangings and deportations of patriotic Indian youths. ... I believe that a nation held in bondage with the help of foreign bayonets is in a perpetual state of war. Since open battle is rendered impossible to a disarmed race, I attacked by surprise; since guns were denied to me, I drew forth my pistol and fired." The statement proceeds: " As a Hindu, I feel that a wrong done to my country is an insult to God." It concluded: “The war of independence will continue between India and England so long as the English and Hindu races last (if this present unnatural relation does not cease)."
This was the statement which Dhingra said he did not remember fully and a copy of which the police had secured at Dhingra’s residence and another on his person. They had no idea that there were more copies in existence. How could Savarkar get a third copy and send it with Varma for being circulated and published all over the world ? Some papers like the London Times openly spoke out their minds by saying that someone must have put these words into Dhingra's mouth ! It was clear beyond doubt that the author of the statement was the leader himself !

Savarkar saw Dhingra in the Brixton Jail on July 22. He said to Madanlal, " I have come to have your Darshan" On hearing the tribute to his sacrifice, glee played over his face and grateful tears appeared in his eyes. Dhingra's last wish was that he should be burnt in conformity with Hindu rites, that no non-Hindu should touch his body, that his clothes and articles should be sold and the money should be donated to the National Fund! Is death more fearless than Madanlal ? How many such peerless jewels has a slave country to dedicate for propitiating the Goddess of Freedom ?

Delighted at the frustration of the police plan, Dhingra embraced gallows on August 17, 1909. His last words as explained in the statement were, " My wish is that I should be born again of the same Mother and that I should die the same death for her again." His dead body was not handed over to the London Hindus. Still Varma performed the funeral obsequies and got his head tonsured according to Hindu rites in honor of the great soul ! Long live Dhingra for the intense love of his country ! They never die who fall in a great cause ! He fell with faith in his mission and in the destiny of his countrymen and love for his Motherland.

Dhingra's deed thrilled the entire world. Huge placards from Irish papers paid glowing tributes to Dhingra : " Ireland honors Madanlal Dhingra who was proud to lay down his life for the sake of his country." Only men like Pandit Jawaharlal Nehru, however, who were then in London seemed to be unconcerned with the momentous deed. Later in life he has ' observed Gandhian Monday' over this thrilling episode even in his  Autobiography .
The storm raised by Dhingra did not immediately subside. Comments continued for a long time.

Mr. W. S. Blunt, author of Secret History oj the English Occupation oj Egypt, wrote about his interview with Mr. Lyne Stevens, the Doctor Royal friend. Blunt says: " He talked about the Dhingra assassination, which seems to have at last convinced his Royal friends that there is something wrong about the state of India. People talk about political assassinations as defeating its own end, but that is nonsense, it is just the shock needed to convince selfish rulers that selfishness has its limits of imprudence. It is like that other fiction that England never yields to threats. My experience is that when England has her face well slapped she apologises, not before." * Blunt further wrote in his Diaries that no Christian martyr ever faced his judges more fearlessly or with greater dignity and remarked that the day of Dhingra's execution would be regarded as one of martyrdom in India for generations.

Lloyd George expressed to Winston Churchill his highest admiration of Dhingra's attitude as a patriot. Churchill shared the same views and quoted with admiration Dhingra's last words as the finest ever made in the name of patriotism. They compared Dhingra with Plutarch's immortal heroes. Lala Hardayal wrote in the first issue of the Bande Mataram, started by Madame Cama: " In times to come, when the British Empire in India shall have been reduced to dust and ashes, Dhingra's monuments will adorn the squares of our chief towns, recalling to the memory of our children the noble life and noble death of one who laid down his life in a far-off land for the cause he loved so well."

Friday, 1 February 2013

Partition of India and Pakistan a historical perspective Part 1



Atlee recalls Lord Wavell .


Lord Wavell was the penultimate governor general of British India and served office between Oct 1943 to Feb 1947. His arduous task after assuming office was to bring consensus between warring factions within  India viz. Indian national congress and Muslim league. His job became further complicated as there was no clear cut message from England whether India should be accorded complete independence . After failing to accomplish his mission he was recalled by Atlee much to the relief of general population in India.



Lord Mountbatten takes office .

Towards the end of March Lord Mountbatten arrived in India and took over the  office as viceroy. India was probably passing it's  worst phase then. There were communal riots  in north and east India . Calcutta had witnessed it’s worst riots thanks to Jinnah and his call for "Direct action".The tension between Hindus and Sikhs on the one hand and Muslims on the other had led to outbreaks of arson, rioting and murder in the major cities of British India especially in the Punjab. Elsewhere too, particularly in the Jat area surrounding Delhi, in western UP. Hindu and Muslim population showed signs of antagonism to each other, the atmosphere was explosive.  Others were in a state of confusion and uncertainty as to which way the wind would blow. 

Apart from communal flare that had engulfed India Political Department was in a total chaos, on one hand Indian national congress under  Gandhi was rooting for united India  on other hand Muslims who did not want to remain in united India and considered it as their religious duty and obligation to prepare for the Pakistan that was to come. British political personalities were at their wit ends about how to resolve this political crisis. To add to all these political turmoil Princely States, did not want to accede to the demands of "united India" they rather preferred to be part of British India than a democratic India where they had no power.


More over in another significant move , Great Britain govt on 20th February, 1947 announced their intention of transferring power to Indian hands by June 1948 so Mountbatten  was running short of time, he had to build consensus between warring factions  . MountBatten had to start immediately.


Mountbatten begins consultation with Indian national Congress and Muslim league


Much contrary to the popular belief Gandhi was neither in favor of partition nor was responsible for partition . In fact he and Khan Abdul Gaffar khan were the only prominent leaders who were dead against partition. Gandhi for his attempt to keep India united was ready to give any sort of concession to Muslim league. Gandhi during his discussion with  Mountbatten told him that he was in favor of handing over the reins of Government to Jinnah with a promise of cooperation by the Congress . Luckily his offer to Jinnah found little support  among his own congress colleagues . Gandhi from then was sidelined for future negotiations by both congress party and Mountbatten himself. Gandhi getting sidelined  meant that the future negotiation responsibility was handed over to Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel,  Pandit Nehru, and Acharya Kripalani (who was the Congress President).

 Note:-**This blogger is of the opinion that partition happened for good , had partition not happened like  Kashmir whole India would have been burning,so Gandhi getting sidelined during negotiation was a blessing in disguise. **


Jinnah, on the other hand, had managed to convince Muslims into believing that their interests will be best served only by having a separate Muslim country.  Jinnah's Muslim league had virtually swept Muslim dominated seats in recently concluded provincial  assembly seats. Popular belief is that Muslims who stayed back were supporters of India. Much contrary to that majority of then Muslims who stayed back were supporters of Jinnah and Pakistan.  . 




Encouraged by Muslim support he was getting for his call for separate Pakistan Jinnah was now adamant on a separate Islamic state .

 The Congress leadership(Sardar Patel , Nehru) on the other hand, by now had realized that it would not be possible to prevent Partition but at the same time did not want concentrated areas of Hindus and Sikhs in the Punjab and Bengal be taken away from them. Patel in particular by this time was convinced that a partnership between the Congress and the League in the administration of the country was impossible. Either the one or the other could alone govern and it was obvious that the League by itself could not do so. At the same time, he realized that the Congress will not be able to run provinces which had a Muslim majority as muslim population was totally against Congress.

Plan for transfer of power:-

Mountbatten's  solution was to divide existing provinces of Bengal and Punjab, of the Muslim districts Assam being given the option of joining the Muslim provinces of Bengal and ascertaining in the N.W.F.P. the wishes of the people of that province. Mountbatten took a middle ground appeasing both congress and Muslim league. His solution of "transfer of authority" to the provinces was concerned the plan suited Jinnah.  "Partition of provinces", plan suited the Congress. N.W.F.P however posed a peculiar problem , it was the only Muslim dominated region which had voted for congress and trusted leadership of Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan. However it was also well known that in case of choice between India and Pakistan people of NWFP would vote for Pakistan. So Khan Abdul Gaffar khan advocated for independent NWFP as he was well aware of the growing Muslim radicalization in Punjab and he wanted to insulate NWFP from Punjabi radicals.


Reaction to Transfer of power:-


Once the outline of Mountbatten's plan became known to the people in Delhi and outside, feverish activity took hold of them. Among the first to act were the Hindu and Sikh legislators of the Punjab who met in New Delhi and passed a resolution in favor of division of that Province. 

Jinnah, on the other hand continued to insist on an undivided Punjab and Bengal and called the partition of these Provinces as 'a sinister move actuated by spite and bitterness'. He also coerced Mountbatten that the option to the NWFP electorate would be limited to choice for Pakistan or India and Not independent NWFP  and  there would be no option for Independence. Khan Abdul  Gaffar khan's to have an interdependent NWFP was was ignored .

. 

Once the Transfer of power plan became public the gradual migration of Hindu families from the Punjab and  N.W.F.P. started brought in its trail problems to Delhi and other places. Stream of these refugees and their tales of woe and  misery   began to  make an impression in their mood of bitterness, disillusionment and at times desperation,  refugees  undoubtedly   accentuated the  problem  of communal  tension  which had already reached its peak. 

On  the  other  hand,  the  Muslim League  was  organizing itself on a militant basis everywhere. With the support that it   had  of a  section  of Government     and     an     important     element    in    the    administrate machinery, the situation was full of explosive   possibilities. 

The press  was  divided  into three,    Anglo-Indian,    Nationalist   and   Muslim  and  in  particular   the cleavage between the latter two in newspapers and periodicals in   regional languages was talking the armed camp mentality from the inner counsels of Government to the forums of expression of public opinion. The general freedom of expression that prevailed was being grossly  abused  and   both sides indulged through insinuations, innuendoes, veiled threats and covert designs was the favorite pastime of those days, of in fuming public opinion and widening communal cleavage.

Personal note: Given the kind of communal tensions prevailing it was prudent for Mountbatten to delay partition plan . This blood bath could have been avoided by proper planning . Mountbatten was in hurry because of deadline given by British govt , but why blame only Mountbatten even congress leaders didn't press for a planned exchange of refugees . 


Further negotiations for transfer of power:-

Quoting from My Reminiscences of Sardar Patel -V Shankar(v Shankar was personal secretory of Sardar Patel):-

"It was this sojourn to the hills(V.Shankar is refering to Simla negotiation) , which was intended to be a period of rest and recreation that marked a turning point in the course of constitutional negotiations. Lord Mountbatten happened to divulge to Pandit Nehru the plan which he had sent to His Majesty's Government, whereupon Pandit Nehru exploded and was desperately looking for an alternative. At the crucial moment he brought forth the solution that had been discussed earlier with Sardar. Finally Lord Mountbatten changed his plans and the scheme of Partition on the basis of two Dominions was conceived and drawn up. I have only to add to that story what transpired at Delhi where Sardar was every day disturbed and agitated at the prospect of anarchy that was threatening to engulf the country and was waiting for a call from Simla. He knew that discussions on constitutional problems would inevitably take place and that a crisis was about to develop. His mind was already made up and when the telephone call came from Simla he was ready to deal with it. That incident is very vivid in my mind. Maniben(Sardar's daughter and unofficial personal secretory), Sardar and myself collected in Sardar's office room after the call came, I think on 9/10 May. The reception was bad because apart from the poor condition of telephone communications between Simla and Delhi, there was interference from Muslim League eavesdroppers. Sardar, who was a little hard of hearing could not follow what V.P.Menon was saying and at the other end Nehru could not hear distinctly what Sardar was saying. Hence the instruments were passed on to V.P. Menon and me. Both of us then began to conduct our conversation as the interpreters of the two illustrious personalities near us, Pandit Nehru near V.P.Menon and Sardar near me. After Menon had given me a gist of what had transpired, which I dutifully conveyed to Sardar, he asked me on behalf of Pandit Nehru to ascertain from Sardar what his views were on the new plan, Sardar conveyed through me to Pandit Nehru that there was no alternative but to accept that plan and that under it we lost only a fraction of India instead of risking the loss of the whole of it. He also told Pandit Nehru that so far as he was concerned he felt that the transfer of power on the basis of Partition and two Dominions was the surest means whatever peace was possible in this sub-continent and of enabling three-fourths of India to seek its own way of a secular life and economic and administrative development. Pandit Nehru seemed to have received this statement of Sardar's views with satisfaction and relief but he asked Sardar whether the Working Committee and Gandhiji would accept it. Sardar's reply was characteristic of him. He told Pandit Nehru that he accepted full responsibility for seeing the scheme through the Working Committee and so far as Gandhiji was concerned he had no doubt that after initial doubts and skepticism he would give way and see their point of view. Pandit Nehru finally asked Sardar if in that case he should go ahead and Sardar's reply was a very firm affirmative."

A conversation which shaped the future of negotiation from congress side with British India. Important point here to note is that both Sardar and Nehru had come to the conclusion that partition was the only viable option , Nehru though was convinced about partition was worried about how his party colleagues more importantly Gandhi would take this . Sardar on other hand commanded the maximum support in working CWC , he was confident that he would be able to convince CWC . Gandhi still believed that partition wasn't an option , he also was of the opinion that if partition is unavoidable then let it happen after British leave India. How ever Jinnah was adamant on Transfer of power only after partition hence Gandhi's solution wasn't a practical one.

Disclaimer: 
Article is based on two books :-
1.My Reminiscences of Sardar Patel by V Shankar
2.Transfer of power in India by V.P.Menon 

Tuesday, 29 January 2013

S.Nijalingappa on Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel


Deputy Prime Minister Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel discussing with Maharaja of Bhavnagar Kirshna Kumar Sinhji (right) about merger of Bhavnagar, in Bombay on January 18, 1948.


Excerpts from forward written by S.Nijalingappa (Freedom fighter , Gandhian , Former CM of Karnataka) from the book "The Collected Works Of Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel by P N Chopra." 

THE one name that stands out most prominently when one thinks of the unity and integrity of India is Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel. I am not sure if anybody among the leaders of the Indian National Congress would have handled it so well, so effectively and so efficiently. His strength, his imagination, his determination, his sagacity and more than his patriotism and his appreciation of the necessity that India should be one united, integrated whole in order that as one nation it may grow in stature from strength to strength from poverty to affluence, in one word a strong nation, which would stand in the front rank of nations and lead them. He knew that unless the Princes numbering 562 merged their states into the Indian Union, one Indian Nation would be impossible. The manner and method he adopted for this noble purpose was an abject lesson unrivaled in world's political history. He cajoled, he flattered, he threatened. Most of them were made to realize that if they did not fall in line, their own subjects would rise against them as Indians. They would not only lose their popularity, they would also lose their identity. Some of the Princes were misled to think that as British paramountcy had ended, they were free and reverted to their original sovereignty. The feeling of the majority of the Princes was so much against it that many of them, specially those of Travancore, Mysore and Bhopal waited till the last bastion, viz. Nizam's Hyderabad have had to face a police-cum-military action which was brief and complete. This achievement of making one integrated and united India was almost entirely of Sardar's.
One great quality of Sardar is often missed. That is his human approach to problems and human kindness and sympathy. I can quote many instances. The one most pronounced is the way in which he saw to it that after the Princes agreed on his advice or otherwise to merge their States into our Union, standard of life to which they were accustomed from birth was continued at the same level. That this good arrangement was changed after his death to their disadvantage is another matter.
One shudders at the thought what would have happened if these states had not been merged in. Not only India would have been politically not one but torn up into fragments with each bit having different governments, different laws, indeed different in everything, making it impossible for its sustained growth and development socially, politically, economically, culturally, an India weak in every way. This is where Sardar's greatness lies.